The Stigma on “Boomerang Kids” is Culturally Biased

Leave it to another ignorant Yahoo article to inspire one of my rant posts.  However, I feel like this one – titled “How long is too long to live with your parents?” – embodies some popular perceptions that I would like to clear up.

Basically, the article laments that young adults nowadays are living too long in their parents’ homes before moving out and starting an independent life for themselves (hence the nickname “boomerang kids”.)  This post is actually not about the already widely-used counterarguments against this accusation: the state of the economy, the unemployment rate, etc.  I am arguing that there is nothing wrong with a child living with their parents provided that they themselves achieve financial independence.

I realize that this article focuses on deadbeat college graduates who are taking a little too long to find a job or get into graduate school.  But there is a huge disparity in Western and non-Western attitudes when it comes to families of different generations living in the same home, and I felt the need to explain some things.

I will first start with some background on myself: I grew up in a particularly diverse area of San Francisco, where there is a large population of Asian and Hispanic descent.  I myself come from a mixed South Asian/Middle Eastern background. (My mother is Pakistani originally and my father Iranian.  How this union came about is for another story.  Also, if you have read my other blogs, you will understand why I initially left out this tidbit of information.  My current lifestyle and my cultural upbringing completely butt heads, and might have caused cognitive dissonance in some readers.  I, however, was actually born in London, which is where my parents picked up the name ‘Emma’.)

The reason I shared this information is because in many Hispanic and Asian cultures, it is normal for extended families and multiple generations to live together. They are referred to as “multigenerational households” in anthropological terms.  For example, in Pakistan, my grandparents, aunts, uncles, and my cousins all live in the same apartment building.  This is completely normal.  Two of my cousins are in their 30’s and have jobs and everything, but it is still acceptable for them to continue living in their childhood homes.

This lifestyle, thus, also translates to places in the West (like America or London), where many people from South Asia or Latin America relocate.  In San Francisco, I have many Hispanic neighbors who are, in fact, multigenerational households. Meaning the grandparents, in-laws, parents, and lastly the children all live under one roof.  The parents are not deadbeats living on welfare.  They have careers and send their children to school. Once the parents achieve financial independence, their roles switch to becoming caretakers for THEIR parents and becoming the ones who pay rent/mortgage.

The entrance of multigenerational households into the nuclear household structure is akin to fitting a square inside a circle.  America just doesn’t get it yet.  The aforementioned article also pushes an assumption very tightly ingrained into the notion of the American dream: that every American aspires to become a homeowner by their 30’s.  This is also around the time they get married and start a family.  It is just a widely accepted rite of passage.  It never occurs to these traditionally-minded people that if a family decides to own a home, it is a transition that can actually be shared with other, extended family members.

In conclusion, I just want to lay it down that a young adult can, in fact, live with their family and still be financially responsible and productive, especially if they are the ones who later end up taking care of the house and family.  The article just pushes a very unnecessary negative stigma against extended families/multigenerational households, insisting that anyone who does not move out of their childhood home by the time they’re 18-21 years old cannot grow and mature otherwise.  I admit that I myself prefer to live on my own when my mother would gladly have me live with her for the rest of my life. (I currently live separately from my parents in my college town, where I work as a research assistant), But I don’t judge those who do otherwise.  I mean, what is wrong with wanting to spend your life with your family? Nothing.

About emma

My name is Emma, and this is another blog where you will encounter my ramblings and musings about various things.
This entry was posted in Controversey and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to The Stigma on “Boomerang Kids” is Culturally Biased

  1. As a 31 year old who’s currently living at his folks place (albeit due to blowing my savings on the trip of a lifetime), I just wanted to say, “well said.”

  2. arlindarlin says:

    I love what you wrote and I have seen so many of my friends move out of their parents house only to have to move back because they just can’t do it on their own. It’s very tough now a days for a college education to spring board into a true career with a bachelors. It’s heartbreaking but a reality for the young adults of today. You spend a fortune on an education that can’t hold up its end of the bargain, short term at least.

    • emma says:

      Thank you! Yes, people are making too many accusations without realizing the circumstances. I myself had to move back in with my parents for 4 months after graduating before landing a job. Not everyone has a stable career waiting for them after college!

  3. Michele Shaw says:

    Emma, I really appreciate the way you presented this article – you simply pointed out a different perspective rather than adopting a defensive attitude about the situation. I am 44, and I grew up in a multi-generational household, and in fact only moved out when I got married at the age of 22. We have lived on our own for approximately 5 years out of the 22 years we have been married – the remainder of the time we (including our 2 daughters, ages 18 and 21) have lived with his parents, as well as his sister and her children. While many folks have judged us because of this, I simply take a different perspective – not only am I blessed to have family that is emotionally close enough to live together, but our children have been raised with the benefit of knowing their grandparents in a manner that is sadly lacking in Western society today.

    We have had our struggles (10 people in the same house can be a bit taxing at times, especially when the children are so close in age – ours are 21 and 18, his sister’s kids are 18, 17, and 12) but the benefits outweigh the difficulties by far, at least in my opinion. Yes, it would be nice to live in our own place, but at the same time it is such a blessing to have such a bond with different family members that others who have not had the pleasure of knowing or spending so much time with theirs may not really grasp. Of course, not every person is fortunate enough to have family members with which they want to, or even can, be around for any number of reasons. This is one of the major aspects of appreciation I have for looking at it as such a positive experience.

    I truly believe Western society is going to continue seeing an increase in these extended/multigenerational households for many reasons – especially financial – but it is my hope that along with these changing circumstances will come the knowledge and appreciation for the benefits this type of living situation can provide. It really is all about perspective, and your article has definitely provided a positive one from which others may learn to see things differently.

    • emma says:

      Thank you very much! I appreciate your comment. Yes, I just wanted to point out in the midst of negative media that not every parent is praying to kick their kids out of the house. But I chalked it up to cultural differences. And thank you for sharing your experience! There are definitely pros and cons to each way of living.

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s